Three hundred and thirty-four, and no more

Mark Taylor was 112 not out at the close of the first day at Peshawar, and nobody made much of it. He had gone two years averaging under 40. He was captaining a side that had privately discussed replacing him, and he knew it.

A hundred bought him the next Test. That was all it was expected to buy.

Then he batted through the second day as well.

Twelve hours

He was 112 at the close of the first day. On the second he added 222 more, which is a day’s work most Test batsmen never have, and he did 113 of it before lunch.

He put on 279 with Justin Langer, an Australian record against Pakistan for any wicket. Along the way he passed Bradman’s career aggregate for Australia. Then 7,000 Test runs. Then Greg Chappell.

He faced 564 deliveries across 720 minutes. Thirty-two fours. One six.

At the close of the second day he was 334 not out. That is precisely the score Don Bradman made against England at Leeds in 1930, and it had stood as the highest by an Australian in a Test for sixty-eight years.

Full scorecard: Pakistan v Australia, 2nd Test, Peshawar, 15–19 October 1998 →

It was also, in the plainest terms, the innings that saved his job. A captain averaging under 40 for two years does not usually get a third year. A captain who has just made the highest score by an Australian in Test cricket does.

The declaration

Australia were 599 for four. Taylor declared overnight, before a ball was bowled on the third morning, with himself unbeaten on a number he could have passed with a push into the covers.

The Australian dressing room, by several accounts of that evening, wanted him to bat on. There was something close to a vote. He declared anyway, and timed it to give his bowlers the longest possible run at twenty Pakistani wickets.

What it bought

Pakistan made 580 for nine declared. Saeed Anwar 126. Ijaz Ahmed 155. Inzamam-ul-Haq 97. The pitch that was supposed to reward a bowling side with time in hand rewarded nobody.

Australia batted again, Taylor made 92, and the match was drawn.

So the declaration produced nothing. Not a win, not a lead worth pressing, not even a fourth innings to bowl in. Australia arrived in Peshawar one up and left it one up.

The 334 and the 92 did make Taylor the second man in history to score 400 runs in a Test, after Graham Gooch at Lord’s in 1990. That record exists because of the innings he declined to extend, which is either an irony or a consolation depending on how much you think records are worth.

Set against that, the declaration reads differently. A man two years out of form, on the highest score of his life, with the record for the highest score by an Australian sitting one run away, chose to stop. Whatever else it was, it was not a decision made by somebody who needed the runs.

The other man who was stopped

Fifty years earlier at Poona, Bhausaheb Nimbalkar was nine short of the highest score ever made in first-class cricket when the opposition captain took his side off the field and refused to continue. Nimbalkar never got the nine runs. He never played a Test either.

Taylor stopped himself, at a number he had already reached rather than one he was nine short of. The two men sit at opposite ends of the same question, which is who gets to decide when an innings is finished, and whether the batsman is on that list.

What is not on the card

Why he did it.

Taylor has given versions over the years. Respect for Bradman. The needs of the side. A general dislike of individual records. None of them contradicts the others and none of them contradicts anything else on the record, which is exactly the problem: there is no way to choose between three explanations that all fit.

Nor is it possible to establish when he decided. Whether he worked it out in the last over of the day, or had known since the middle of the afternoon what he was going to do when he got there.

The scorecard records a declaration at 599 for four and a drawn Test match. It has a column for runs, a column for balls, a column for minutes and a column for the manner of dismissal. It has no column for a man deciding what his own innings is worth.

••••••

No. 2 in Declared, a series of 2.

Later todayThe innings that never happened