Penalty time

Law 24 begins by allowing something and then spends the rest of its length restricting it. The umpires "shall allow a substitute fielder" if they are satisfied a player has been injured or fallen ill during the match, "or for any other wholly acceptable reason". That is the permission. Everything after it is a condition.

What a substitute is

A fielder, and only a fielder. Clause 24.1.2: "A substitute shall not bowl or act as captain but may act as wicket-keeper only with the consent of the umpires." Three jobs, three answers. Bowling, no. Captaincy, no. Keeping wicket, only if the umpires agree.

The clause does not mention batting. A substitute is defined as a substitute fielder, and the word is doing all the work: the person is on the field for one purpose, and the Law names the purpose before it names the person.

Leaving the field

A player who leaves the field must have the reason given to an umpire, and may not come back on during a session without the umpire's consent. Going briefly outside the boundary on fielding duties, clause 24.2.1 says, is not being absent at all: a fielder chasing a ball over the rope has not left.

Then the clause that gives the Law its shape. The returning player "shall not be permitted to bowl, until having been back on the field of play for a period of time known as Penalty time".

Penalty time

The absence is repaid in presence. A player who has been off the field must be back on it for as long as the Law requires before bowling, and the Law closes the gap in a separate clause: not until all of it has been served. Clause 24.2.3 caps it. "A player's unserved Penalty time shall be limited to a maximum of 90 minutes."

So the debt is measured in time and capped at an hour and a half. A bowler absent for a session owes the same as one absent for a day. The cap is the Law deciding that beyond ninety minutes the punishment stops tracking the offence, and it says so in one sentence without explaining why ninety.

When there is no debt

Clause 24.3 lists two cases. A player who "has suffered an external blow during the match and, as a result, has justifiably left the field" owes nothing. Nor does a player absent "for other wholly acceptable reasons" in the umpires' opinion. The first is a fact about the body. The second is a judgement, and the phrase "wholly acceptable" appears twice in the Law, once to allow the substitute and once to excuse the absence.

Coming back unasked

Clause 24.4 covers the player who returns to the field without permission and touches the ball. "The ball shall immediately become dead", and the umpire "shall award 5 Penalty runs to the batting side". The player has not merely fielded illegally; the act of fielding has ended the ball and cost five.

It is the only clause in the Law with a number of runs in it, and it is aimed at the one thing the rest of the Law cannot otherwise stop: a fielder deciding for themselves that they are back.

The nominated player

Clause 24.1.3 restores the balance. A nominated player "may bowl or field even though a substitute has previously acted for him/her", subject to the Penalty time clauses and to Law 42.4. The substitute is temporary. The nominated player's rights survive the absence, minus the time owed.

That is the Law in one line. Eleven names go in before the toss, under Law 1, and Law 24 is the set of terms on which one of them can be missing for a while without the eleven becoming ten.

Law 24, Fielders’ absence; Substitutes: MCC Laws of Cricket, 2017 Code →

Law 1, The players: MCC Laws of Cricket, 2017 Code →

••••••

No. 12 in By the Book, a series of 17.

NextBefore the toss