Declared on 194

Virender Sehwag made 309 at Multan, the first triple century by an Indian in seventy-two years of Test cricket. It is not what the match is remembered for.

India had never won a Test in Pakistan and had not played one there for fourteen years, the two boards having spent most of that period unable to agree that a tour should happen at all. When the 2004 series was finally arranged it carried more weight than cricket is usually asked to hold.

The second day

Sehwag was out at 509, having faced 375 balls. Sachin Tendulkar had been at the other end for a stand of 336 of them.

He batted on. With VVS Laxman, and then with Yuvraj Singh, through the afternoon, while the score went past 600 and then past 650 and the match stopped being a contest.

Yuvraj was caught and bowled by Imran Farhat for 59. That made it 675 for five, and Tendulkar was on 194.

Rahul Dravid, captaining because Sourav Ganguly was injured, declared.

Tendulkar was 194 not out from 348 balls. He had been six runs away for about eleven minutes.

Full scorecard: Pakistan v India, 1st Test, Multan, 28 March–1 April 2004 →

There is a detail on the card that sharpens all of this. Dravid was not the appointed captain; he was standing in. And when he had batted, earlier in the same innings, he had made 6.

The case for it

India had 675 on the board with three days and a session left, on a surface that was going to deteriorate. Twenty wickets were required. Every over spent adding to a total that was already unassailable was an over not spent taking them.

It worked exactly as designed. Pakistan made 407 and followed on. Anil Kumble took six in the second innings, Irfan Pathan six in the match, and Pakistan were bowled out for 216.

India won by an innings and 52 runs. Their first Test win in Pakistan, in their first Test in Pakistan for fourteen years, and it was not close.

The case against it

Six runs.

Not sixty. Tendulkar was scoring at a shade over fifty per hundred balls and would have needed two overs, perhaps three. Pakistan were then dismissed twice with more than a day to spare, so those two overs cost nothing that can be identified anywhere on the card.

And a double hundred in Pakistan is not a small thing to take off the batsman who had carried Indian expectation, more or less alone, for fifteen years.

India went on to win the series 2–1. It remains the only time they have won a Test series in Pakistan, and Multan is the match that made it possible. Every argument against the declaration has to be made from inside a tour that could hardly have gone better.

What was said

Tendulkar said he was taken by surprise. John Wright, the coach, has written that Tendulkar felt let down.

Dravid has said the decision was his, that he would make it again, and separately that he wished it had been handled better. Both of those can be true. A captain can be right about the cricket and wrong about the man, and know it.

None of the accounts contradicts the others. That is precisely why the episode has lasted. Everybody behaved defensibly and the outcome still felt wrong to the person it happened to, which is a harder thing to resolve than a straightforward mistake.

What would settle it

Nothing available.

The match was won by an innings, so the declaration cannot be shown to have been necessary. It cannot be shown to have been unnecessary either, because a captain never gets to watch the match he chose not to play.

What the card records is 675 for five declared. Directly above it, on the line for the man who was still in, it records Sachin Tendulkar, not out, 194.

It is the most eloquent thing on the page and nobody put it there on purpose. Scorecards do not editorialise. They record who was out and how, and for the men who were not out they record only that, and the number they had reached when somebody else decided the innings was over.

••••••

No. 4 in Declared, a series of 15.

NextEleven overs